Evaluating Spectral Resolution Effects on Crop Monitoring: A Comparison of UAV-based Multispectral, Hyperspectral and handheld Greenseeker sensor

Abstract

Spectral sensors have become an integral part of modern precision agriculture. It enables fast, non-destructive and map-based crop monitoring of key crop physiological parameters. The spectral resolution of a sensor plays an important role in determining its ability to detect subtle changes in the crop, nutrient status and canopy development. Sensor’s comparison based on spectral resolution remains limited particularly in the context of field-level agronomic monitoring. This study aims to address this gap by using three sensors UAV-based multispectral (MS), UAV-based hyperspectral (HS) and handheld Greenseeker (GS) NDVI measurements. Hyperspectral sensors provide continuous high-resolution data from visible to near infrared; MS use fewer broad bands; GS limits to two bands for quick NDVI field checks. The experimental study was conducted in the arid region of Uttar Pradesh, India. The experimental setup consisted of plots with same irrigation (100% ETc) and varying nitrogen dosage i.e. 150,120 and 90 kg/ha (Plot 1, Plot 2 and Plot 3, respectively) with three replications. Plots 4 and 5, representing farmer-field conditions with 120 kg ha⁻¹ nitrogen and no nitrogen respectively, followed regional irrigation practices, whereas Plot 6 (rainfed) was irrigated only once initially. A series of UAV-flights were conducted across critical phenological stages, and the reflectance was used to generate Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) representing canopy density.The results showed that NDVI rapidly increased during early vegetative stage (61-75) DAS, saturated around (75-85) DAS, followed by a decline during (101-117) DAS. NDVI peaked around flowering stage for all the sensors. GS-NDVI varied between (0.46-0.78), MS-NDVI displayed (0.52-0.86), whereas HS- NDVI varied between (0.55-0.90). The mean NDVI values were (0.570 ± 0.085) for GS, (0.608 ± 0.075) for MS, and (0.664 ± 0.087) for the HS, with HS exceeding others by 16.5% (vs. GS) and 9.3% (vs. MS). Pearson correlation coefficients confirm strong inter-sensor agreement: Greenseeker-Hyperspectral r = 0.96, Multispectral-Hyperspectral r = 0.91, Greenseeker-Multispectral r = 0.87 (all p

Plant phenotyping relevance

複数のセンサーによる作物キャノピーNDVI測定を比較し、スペクトル分解能とセンサー間一致度を評価することが研究の中心であるため、植物フェノタイピング手法の技術比較・検証に該当する。

Code and data availability

公開論文であることは確認できましたが、現在の公式API・許可済み取得経路では本文を自動取得できませんでした。

No evidence-backed public reproduction asset is currently recorded.