Maize tassels detection: a benchmark of the state of the art.

Abstract

BACKGROUND: The population of plants is a crucial indicator in plant phenotyping and agricultural production, such as growth status monitoring, yield estimation, and grain depot management. To enhance the production efficiency and liberate labor force, many automated counting methods have been proposed, in which computer vision-based approaches show great potentials due to the feasibility of high-throughput processing and low cost. In particular, with the success of deep learning, more and more deeper learning-based approaches are introduced to deal with agriculture automation. Since different detection- and regression-based counting models have distinct characteristics, how to choose an appropriate model given the target task at hand remains unexplored and is important for practitioners. RESULTS: Targeting in-field maize tassels as a representative case study, the goal of this work is to present a comprehensive benchmark of state-of-the-art object detection and object counting methods, including Faster R-CNN, YOLOv3, FaceBoxes, RetinaNet, and the leading counting model of maize tassels-TasselNet. We create a Maize Tassel Detection Counting (MTDC) dataset by supplementing bounding box annotations to the Maize Tassels Counting (MTC) dataset to allow the training of detection models. We investigate key factors effecting the practical applications of the models, such as convergence behavior, scale robustness, speed-accuracy trade-off, as well as parameter sensitivity. Based on our benchmark, we summarise the advantages and limitations of each method and suggest several possible directions to improve current detection- and regression-based counting approaches to benefit next-generation intelligent agriculture. CONCLUSIONS: error. While detection-based methods are more robust than regression-based methods in scale variations and can infer extra information (e.g., object positions and sizes), the latter ones have significantly faster convergence behaviors and inference speed. To choose an appropriate in-filed plant counting method, accuracy, robustness, speed and some other algorithm-specific factors should be taken into account with the same priority. This work sheds light on different aspects of existing detection and counting approaches and provides guidance on how to tackle in-field plant counting. The MTDC dataset is made available at https://git.io/MTDC.

Plant phenotyping relevance

トウモロコシ雄穂の検出・計数という植物形質の取得を対象に、複数の画像認識手法をベンチマークし、専用データセットも構築しているため、表現型計測手法が中心である。

Code and data availability

The paper's MTDC dataset (MTC maize tassel images with new bounding box annotations, 13,562 boxes) is explicitly released publicly at the authors' URL https://git.io/MTDC, stated in both the abstract and Data Availability Statement. No author analysis code or trained model checkpoints are explicitly deposited.