Phenomics data processing: A plot-level model for repeated measurements to extract the timing of key stages and quantities at defined time points

Abstract

Decision-making in breeding increasingly depends on the ability to capture and predict crop responses to changing environmental factors. Advances in crop modeling as well as high-throughput field phenotyping (HTFP) hold promise to provide such insights. Processing HTFP data is an interdisciplinary task that requires broad knowledge on experimental design, measurement techniques, feature extraction, dynamic trait modeling, and prediction of genotypic values using statistical models. To get an overview of sources of variation in HTFP, we develop a general plot-level model for repeated measurements. Based on this model, we propose a seamless step-wise procedure that allows for carry on of estimated means and variances from stage to stage. The process builds on the extraction of three intermediate trait categories; (1) timing of key stages, (2) quantities at defined time points or periods, and (3) dose-response curves. In a first stage, these intermediate traits are extracted from low-level traits’ time series (e.g., canopy height) using P-splines and the quarter of maximum elongation rate method (QMER), as well as final height percentiles. In a second and third stage, extracted traits are further processed using a stage-wise linear mixed model analysis. Using a wheat canopy growth simulation to generate canopy height time series, we demonstrate the suitability of the stage-wise process for traits of the first two above-mentioned categories. Results indicate that, for the first stage, the P-spline/QMER method was more robust than the percentile method. In the subsequent two-stage linear mixed model processing, weighting the second and third stage with error variance estimates from the previous stages improved the root mean squared error. We conclude that processing phenomics data in stages represents a feasible approach if estimated means and variances are carried forward from one processing stage to the next. P-splines in combination with the QMER method are suitable tools to extract timing of key stages and quantities at defined time points from HTFP data.

Plant phenotyping relevance

HTFP時系列から生育段階の時期やキャノピー形質を抽出し、段階的な統計処理を行う汎用データ処理手法の開発・検証が中心である。

Code and data availability

The paper's Data availability statement explicitly declares that the data and source code supporting the study (the FIP plot-level phenotyping pipeline with P-splines/QMER trait extraction) are openly available in the authors' public ETH GitLab repository, with an archived ETH research-collection DOI.